Journaling was a big part of the first experiential courses I led in the Sierra Nevada. When I asked senior instructors why, nobody had a solid answer.
The best I got was, “It gives students something to take home so they remember the course.” That raised more questions than it answered:
- Does journaling work?
- What do we want students to remember?
- Which journaling techniques work best in the field?
I've watched journaling fade from many programs in recent years. I think it's because staff and administrators still have open questions. Who provides the journals? Where do we find the time? Do we train instructors to use them?
Those questions matter. The research gives a clear answer on the big one. Journaling is worth the time, and it pays off for students.
The 5 reasons
Journaling logistics
The Alpenglow method: four prompts
There are thousands of journaling techniques. At Alpenglow, we use one rooted in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT). It's simple and safe, even if you're not a trained therapist.
Give students a pen, paper and a safe place to write. Tell them they have about 10 minutes. Then give them four prompts:
This teaches students to walk through an experience in order: event, thoughts, feelings and actions. It helps them make sense of the course and how they responded to it. That builds lifelong learning and reinforces the lessons from your course.
When journaling isn't a fit
Journaling isn't a silver bullet. Start by asking, “Is journaling productive and possible for this student?” Some students with mental or behavioral health concerns may struggle with it. Others feel embarrassed by their writing. Try these accommodations:
Start this season
Journaling gives students time, space and a structure to process their experiences. That structure helps prevent mental and behavioral health episodes on course. There's no right or wrong way to journal. Doing something beats doing nothing.
- Crawford, A., Sellman, E., & Joseph, S. (2021). Journaling: A more mindful approach to researching a mindfulness-based intervention in a junior school. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 20.
- Hubbs, D. L., & Brand, C. F. (2005). The paper mirror: Understanding reflective journaling. Journal of Experiential Education, 28(1), 60-71.
- Sutton, M. J., & Jorge, C. F. B. Phenomenological approach to applying reflective journaling to experiential learning. Journal of Applied Learning and Teaching, 4(Sp. Iss. 1), 31-49.
