The Benefits of Getting It Wrong

The Everyday Practice of Empathy

By Becca Wallingford  |  Originally published June 5, 2020  |  5 minute read

Two people holding hands in support

I don't feel like myself today. I'm not sure why, but the symptoms of a national uprising, racial injustice, and loved ones not understanding the severity or seeking to look at the other side to recognize their frustrations seem to culminate in a feeling of total helplessness. In recent normal fashion, I turn to social worker and researcher Dr. Brené Brown and her research on shame and empathy to dive into this storm of emotions, reactions, and conversations.

Dr. Brown discusses multiple ways in which empathy is a practiced choice that can be (and mostly is) incredibly vulnerable. It requires us to recognize that we are learners instead of knowers, that we will inevitably fail to connect with some around us and must circle back to truly listen instead of project shame. Although the concept of empathy is often discussed, it is much more difficult to connect its idealist definition to everyday practice. In order to live by its philosophy, it is essential to expound on what it is and, more importantly, what it isn't.

According to the National Association of Social Workers, empathy is defined as:

“The act of perceiving, understanding, experiencing, and responding to the emotional state and ideas of another person.”

A large body of research examines the connection empathy builds through everyday habits and the benefits of including it in policymaking, program development, and relationships.

First, it is essential to recognize that empathy is not finite. The more we practice it, the more it spreads to those around us. Dr. Theresa Wiseman, a nursing researcher who studies empathy, describes it as four attributes: perspective, practicing non-judgment, understanding, and communication. Dr. Kristin Neff, who specializes in self-compassion, adds a lens on how our sense of self shapes all four. To dig into the everyday practice of empathy as social workers, outdoor professionals, and humans, I want to dissect each of these elements and their applications.

1

Perspective

It is easy to recognize we each come from our own perspective based on our history and experiences when we are not emotionally charged. But when others act in ways we don't immediately understand, we all inevitably look at events through the lens in which we see the world around us. Often, our first reaction is to blame ignorance. And although we may try as much as possible, it can be impossible to interpret those events through the eyes of another person. This is very difficult to digest for most of us, who like to think of ourselves as compassionate and understanding people. This instead can often get us into trouble.

As a white woman, I have never experienced the terror of being pulled over by a cop or heard hushed undertones of discrimination against me. Our point of view, no matter how hard we try, is a product of our personal history, our familial history, and only our own experiences.

To be empathetic means to accept that we must often be learners instead of knowers.

That is the shared conclusion of Dr. Brown, Dr. Wiseman, and Dr. Neff. We all have blind spots based on these parts of ourselves, no matter how many documentaries, narratives, or stories we listen to. To just be a listener can often be uncomfortable, but to show authentic empathy is to sit in that discomfort and recognize the ways we can connect through emotions instead of judge or display sympathy in our disconnection.

2

Practicing Non-Judgment

It is nearly impossible to go through our lives without judging others, and those who claim to are often trapped in a thick armor of shame. According to social work research, we can predict the times and ways we are going to judge in two ways: (1) we are most susceptible to judge others in the areas where we most often feel shame or critique ourselves, and (2) even more so toward others who are doing worse in those areas, according to our own perspectives.

I was recently watching the Amazon film Brittany Runs a Marathon, which depicted this perfectly. The main character feels immense shame about her weight, as most of us women can relate to, and projects this onto another person when she is feeling at her lowest. While hating to admit it, I have felt this way in my darkest moments of low self-esteem, shame, and self-pity.

To escape the cycle of judgment, we must recognize the areas within ourselves where we feel the most vulnerable. By acknowledging our own struggles, we can quickly raise a red flag when we find ourselves beginning to judge. Does that mean we will stop and be cured of this kind of attitude? Absolutely not. Instead, we can begin taking small steps to be more aware of times when we begin to build armor to seemingly protect ourselves from self-doubt and shame. This also requires the first attribute of empathy: understanding our perspective and moving forward with awareness of our privilege, struggles, and history.

3

Understanding

Dr. Neff discusses how recognizing and dissecting our sense of self is essential to how we present ourselves to others. By practicing this, we are better able to look into another's viewpoint while also distinguishing the ways in which we can never truly live in their shoes. By staying aware of our implicit biases and our sense of self, we develop a wide array of sensitivity, which creates a space where empathy can be upheld. This also allows each one of us to grow in intrapersonal development and gain a better sense of self.

4

Communication

Although we are taught the power of communication from a very young age, we so often find ourselves at a loss for words while experiencing deep emotion. If I could count how many times someone asked me, “What's wrong?” and I answered with “I don't know,” well, there would be a lot of numerical digits. During these times I often couldn't pinpoint a concrete source and would instead fall into a spiral that was difficult to explain. “I don't know” made the most sense if I didn't want to enter the rabbit hole and leave the questioning or concerned person wide-eyed.

I have recently been trying to change this conversation by being honest with those I know will listen. In a recent answer to my concerned husband, I didn't hold back. After about two minutes of a stream-of-consciousness breakdown that left me in tears, he simply answered: “Well, there's a lot to unpack there.”

He didn't try to fix it. He asked clarifying questions to gain a deeper understanding of my feelings, and when he didn't understand, he asked some more. This was empathy. He got things wrong but kept asking. I left feeling supported, loved, and, although not understood, relieved.

Empathy cannot thrive if communication fails. Communication is also the biggest risk and the part most likely to keep us from participating fully. My husband got things wrong, and I guarantee we all will. He didn't pretend to fully understand my experience or downward spiral of anxiety, because I carry my own history and baggage.

To practice authentic empathy means to get it wrong, ask for forgiveness, and try again.

This is not possible without connection, which is where the elephant in the room lies. How can we be allies to those who are continually oppressed when we keep getting it wrong?

Further reading and listening

  • Theresa Wiseman (2007). Toward a holistic conceptualization of empathy for nursing practice. ANS. Advances in Nursing Science, 30(3), E61–E72.
  • Self-Compassion Exercises, Dr. Kristin Neff
  • Dare to Lead, Dr. Brené Brown
  • How to Be an Antiracist, Ibram X. Kendi
  • “The Showdown at Lafayette Square,” The Daily, New York Times podcast
  • Uprising Resources, Kris Hampton
  • “The Trauma of Being Black in America,” 1A, NPR podcast

Bring this into the field

A participant answers “I don't know” on Day 3 of a trip. Behavioral First Responder Level 1 gives your staff a framework to listen, assess and refer. 8 hours, in person, built by outdoor educators.

See upcoming BFR courses